Belize - Belize News - - Great Belize Productions - Belize Breaking News
Home » Featured, Trials » Rhett Fuller’s extradition case wraps up in Appeals Court
Oct 22, 2012

Rhett Fuller’s extradition case wraps up in Appeals Court

Rhett Fuller

The Rhett Fuller extradition case continued in Appeals Court today. On Friday the Court of Appeals rejected as evidence, two cables released by the website Wikileaks. The cables revealed that the Minister of Foreign Affairs and Attorney General, Wilfred Elrington, held meetings with U.S. Embassy representatives regarding the extradition process of Fuller and Mark Seawell, who the US also wants to try. Today, Fuller’s attorney, Eamon Courtenay, argued several points in the Appeals Court Justices where there was one absentia, Justice Samuel Awich. Prior to being appointed to the Appeals Court, Awich ruled against Fuller in the Supreme Court. So Courtenay’s arguments included rebuttals to Awich’s ruling and Elrington’s acceptance of a Privy Council judgment rather than forming his own as the government representative with the authority to decide whether or not Fuller stays in the country. News Five spoke to Courtenay as he exited the Appeals Court Chamber late this evening.


Eamon Courtenay, Attorney for Rhett Fuller

Eamon Courtenay

“The entire basis of the application was to try to establish that Mister Justice Awich did not consider our submissions. We had submitted that Minister Elrington did not properly weigh the evidence that Mister Fuller had put before him and that in fact what he did was that he looked at what the Privy Council had said and said oh I come to the same conclusion. Mister Justice Awich seems to be saying that he agrees with that. Our submission to the court is that Rhett Fuller Decision in the Privy Council has nothing to do with what was before the Minister. And once; we hope that if we convince them of that that our next point will be that when you look at the evidence you would see that Justice Awich did not deal with complaints that Mister Fuller was raising. I think that you can see that the Court was giving me a warm time with the arguments as they did to Miss Perdomo. The judicial process is ended and now it is for the minister to make a decision as a minister. Is this the way I want to treat a Belizean? Should a Belizean who has been made to wait for eight years before a request for extradition is come; should that person be sent? The minister has to consider, why is it that the American’s did not disclose all the contacts that they had with Mister Fuller prior to them making the request for extradition? Another important factor that the Minister absolutely did not look at which the cases say he can look at is the effect of this on his family. Mister Fuller has a daughter that is suffering from autism and what is the effect of that on Mister Fuller’s daughter; Mister Fuller’s family if he is extradited. None of that was considered by the minister and those are the matters that the minister ought to have taken into account and to determine in our submission that Mister Fuller should not go. And we are saying to the Court that he failed to do this and he failed to do it because he felt that the Privy Council had decided everything already which is wrong.”


If this appeal does not favor his client, Courtenay says an appeal to the Caribbean Court of Justice has not been ruled out as an option.

Viewers please note: This Internet newscast is a verbatim transcript of our evening television newscast. Where speakers use Kriol, we attempt to faithfully reproduce the quotes using a standard spelling system.

Advertise Here

9 Responses for “Rhett Fuller’s extradition case wraps up in Appeals Court”

  1. Rod says:

    Give it up Rhett judas barrow has already collected his 30 pieces of silver for your hide so just go and face the music or get the belizean people behind you let them see that this corrupt gov. Is giving you up for a few pieces of silver they would give up their mothers for a few pieces of silver much less you . Stand up belizeans help this man out .

  2. Uncle Benji says:

    @Rod……….. well spoken.

  3. alley cat says:

    But Rod, Rhett has been catching heat from even when PUP was in power. Both parties when in power have handed Belizean citizens over to the us, mainly for drug trafficking offenses. This guy is charged with murder, now if he is facing the death penalty in the states then I would say do not comply. I feel bad for his family but he needs to go face the music just like you said. Maybe Carlos or the Puerto Rican will testify in his favor, and yes I do agree that it would be hell for us to get an American citizen to stand trial in Belize after he has absconded to the States…

  4. Stuart says:

    I Have known Rhett along time. I am aware of his case and i think he and his family has been through enough!

  5. Concerned Belizean says:

    Why should we send someone to the US? if they want Rhett let them come for him. It is so diifficult for Belizeans to get a visa just to visit the states needless to say get an american extradicted. I think he has served his time… Let the man go for God sakes.

  6. L.Flo says:

    This &£%$#× case is not worth commenting about any more.The reason his lawyers are continuing his case is because of the large sums they are being paid. HOW MANY MORE APPEALS can the justices endure? How much has it cost the Government so far?

  7. moses says:

    Free Rhett. Screw the USA. Rhett da noh Noriega or Osama. Lef di man lone.

  8. beachman says:

    No surprise Erlington couldn’t make a bright decision about this case. Why have a position when you’re not capable of carrying out yur duties?

  9. Tanya Fuller says:

    As his sister, I can tell you that guilt by association can cost u the rest of ur life. He did not pull the trigger but it matters not to the justice system.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login